Hi Katie,
We are glad you provide your site URL.
And we checked the issue and can you please tell us if you are using some other cache plugins.
Please check all plugins by deactivating them one by one, maybe due to plugin this issue is coming.
In last if anything does not happen by deactivating plugins.
If you want we can check your theme, make a user for us assign administrator role and send us the username and password along with the site URL.
In Case you provide us the Login Details you can send us on
Thanks